Pizza restaurants

Gateway Pizza - ID 83610

4.8 86 reviews Closed 10 W Central Blvd, Cambridge, ID 83610, United States

Discover this place

Gateway Pizza is a pizza restaurant located at 10 W Central Blvd in Cambridge, Idaho. The menu centers on classic and creative pizzas available by the slice or as whole 18-inch pies. Signature offerings include the Primus with red sauce and mozzarella, the Basil topped with fresh basil, and the Shelbie's Garden featuring mushrooms, olives, and onions. The Crossover pizza combines pepperoni, sausage, bacon, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers, while the LNK adds pineapple and jalapenos for a distinctive flavor. Slices range from traditional cheese and pepperoni to more varied options, accompanied by simple sides such as ranch and extra red sauce. The atmosphere at Gateway Pizza is casual, making it suitable for quick bites or relaxed meals. The focus is on straightforward, approachable pizza with familiar and inventive toppings, catering to local tastes in a comfortable setting.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Family-friendly
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Gateway Pizza - ID 83610 before visiting.

Reviews for Gateway Pizza - ID 83610

4.8

86 reviews

100%

Review highlights

Based on 86 reviews

Gateway Pizza in Cambridge, ID consistently receives praise for its high-quality, hand-tossed pizzas featuring flavorful crusts and a diverse range of fresh toppings, from meats to vegetarian options. Reviewers highlight the excellent value for both quantity and quality, noting that the menu’s variety extends beyond pizza to include sandwiches and salads with standout dressings. The atmosphere is frequently described as relaxed and cozy, complemented by attentive and friendly staff who contribute to a welcoming dining experience. Additional touches such as specialty add-ons and unique features like free arcade games enhance customer satisfaction. Overall, Gateway Pizza is recognized as a reliable spot for delicious, thoughtfully prepared food served in a pleasant and inviting environment, encouraging repeat visits from both locals and visitors alike.

Terri Garabedian

Oct 11, 2025

Best pizza we’ve ever had! Hand-tossed with the most delicious crust and amazing toppings from meats to vegetarian options. Great selection of sandwiches & salads too! Atmosphere is relaxed & cozy, owners are super nice and committed to making the highest-quality foods. We’ve gone back many times and the food is always top-notch!

Austin Tague

Sep 29, 2025

If this is on your route you must stop here!!! Don’t skip this one! These pies are obviously made with care and high quality ingredients. The price point for the both the quantity and quality is fantastic ($22 for an 18”). They also do by the slice, but seriously you’re gonna want a whole one. I added home smoked mozzarella to mine for only $1 extra and it was my best decision ever. This small town is blessed to have a pizzeria this good. The only thing that could be better is having one at home. 10/10.

M L

Sep 17, 2025

This place is a gem and a pleasant surprise! Delicious and fresh pizza with a perfect crust... cold beer, free arcade games and very kind and attentive staff/owners. The salads are with spring mix and some of the best ranch dressing ever. We were visiting from out of town and so glad to find Gateway Pizza.

Sheala Gatz

Sep 07, 2025

Great pizza! Very tasty, the dough is delicious. Great homemade ranch!

Hans Sween

Jul 30, 2025

This is a pretty great stop for some high quality pizza. The service was great, good recommendations and they offered upgrades to the salad I ordered with their in-house spicy ranch. The actual pizza was fantastic. Very good size pie with great toppings. I'll definitely be coming here again.

Brandon Emerson

Jul 18, 2025

Very good NYC style pizza. Service was good and though they were crazy busy, they still got our food out quickly. Will be back for sure.

Brett Hunt

Jul 01, 2025

Great pizza has to start with the crust, and this hand tossed pie delivers! This is some of the best pizza in Idaho, with great sauce and perfect ratio of high quality toppings to complement the perfect crust. Ambience is comfortable and hip, with even a few vintage video games to complete the picture. Super friendly service and great beverage selection. Excellent value, the prices are pretty low for what you get.